Post
LIVE

THE REFINED FUEL: They Clocked the Exhaust of 3I/ATLAS at Closest Approach. Half Speed. Wrong Direction. And the Sulfur Is Gone.

A team in Spain just ran the most comprehensive chemical survey of the interstellar object ever attempted at closest approach to the Sun. What they found describes an engine, not a comet.

View original source

Key Claims

7
Factual5Interpretation2
  • A team led by Nicolas Biver at the Paris Observatory measured the gas coming off 3I/ATLAS at 0.37 kilometers per second.factual
    On November 1 through 3, 2025, three days after closest approach to the Sun, a team led by Nicolas Biver at the Paris Observatory pointed Europe’s largest millimeter telescope at 3I/ATLAS and measured the gas coming off the object at peak output.
  • The gas from 3I/ATLAS moves faster toward the Sun than away from it.factual
    The gas moves faster toward the Sun than away from it.
  • The Sentinel Dossier identified the sunward jet as a retro-rocket.interpretation
    The Sentinel Dossier identified the sunward jet as a retro-rocket.
  • The carbon-oxygen chemistry of 3I/ATLAS is loaded, with sulfur absent.factual
    The carbon and oxygen compounds are elevated. Sulfur is gone.
  • The water output of 3I/ATLAS is nine times the capacity of the physical surface.factual
    To produce that much water from the surface alone, the nucleus would need to be nine times its own size in pure exposed ice.
  • Shinnaka's group found carbon dioxide still elevated above typical comets on the outbound leg.factual
    Carbon dioxide was still elevated above typical comets, comparable to the previous interstellar visitor, 2I/Borisov.
  • The drive of 3I/ATLAS was on when the object was far from the Sun and heading in, and it is still on now.interpretation
    The drive was on when the object was far from the Sun and heading in. It is still on now, far from the Sun and heading out.

Evidence

5
IRAM 30-m millimeter spectroscopyBiver et al. (2026)
data
Subaru/HDS optical spectroscopyShinnaka et al. (2026)
data
JUICE/MAJIS infrared
data
SOHO/SWAN Lyman-alpha
data
Sentinel mechanical analysisThe Sentinel
document

Event timeline

3
April 1, 2026

Publication of Biver and Shinnaka papers

The papers by Biver et al. and Shinnaka et al. were published.

January 7, 2026

Shinnaka's group observes 3I/ATLAS

Yoshiharu Shinnaka’s group observed 3I from Hawai’i’s Subaru Telescope.

November 1 through 3, 2025

Biver's team measures 3I/ATLAS

Nicolas Biver's team measured the gas coming off 3I/ATLAS at closest approach.