Post
LIVE

THE CURATED ORBIT: Independent Scientists Just Recovered the Signal NASA Filtered Out.

7,578 observations vs. 782. A sideways force equal to the radial one. A reversal at perihelion. And a nucleus nobody can measure.

View original source

Key Claims

7
Factual6Interpretation1
  • The article states that NASA's CNEOS database was quietly altered within 24 hours of Loeb’s paper, flipping a velocity sign to force an interstellar meteor back into a Solar System origin.factual
    In The Silent Edit, we documented how NASA’s CNEOS database was quietly altered within 24 hours of Loeb’s paper.
  • The article claims that NASA JPL used only 782 observations for 3I/ATLAS, while the independent team used 7,578 observations.factual
    NASA used 782 observations. This team used 7,578.
  • The article states that the sideways force on 3I/ATLAS is equal to the radial force, not a secondary wobble.factual
    The sideways force on 3I is not noise. It is the same magnitude as the radial force.
  • The article claims that the sideways force reversed direction at perihelion.factual
    Before perihelion, the sideways force was strong and positive: +4.48. After perihelion, it effectively collapsed: -0.22.
  • The article claims that the force on 3I/ATLAS peaked 6.97 days before perihelion.factual
    The object was pushing hardest a full week before it was closest to the Sun.
  • The article claims that the nucleus size of 3I/ATLAS could be as small as 1.5 km, challenging the comet model.interpretation
    The nucleus could be 3 km. Or it could be 1.5 km.
  • The article claims that the trajectory solution for 3I/ATLAS shifts dramatically when removing a few spacecraft observations.factual
    The entire picture of what is pushing this object shifted dramatically because a few lucky measurements from two spacecraft were removed.

Evidence

5
arXiv:2603.00782v1 paperFederico Spada, Luke Dones, Malgorzata Krolikowska
paper
NASA JPL's 782 observationsNASA JPL
data
7,578 observations by independent teamFederico Spada, Luke Dones, Malgorzata Krolikowska
data
Hubble images showing geometryHubble Space Telescope
image
Psyche and Trace Gas Orbiter observationsNASA Psyche, ESA Trace Gas Orbiter
data

Event timeline

4
May 2025

TESS pre-discovery images

TESS captured pre-discovery images of 3I/ATLAS.

October 29

Perihelion of 3I/ATLAS

The point of closest approach to the Sun for 3I/ATLAS.

February 28

Paper posted on arXiv

A team of three researchers posted a new analysis to arXiv.

6.97 days before perihelion

Force peak before perihelion

The force on 3I/ATLAS peaked 6.97 days before perihelion.