Post
LIVE

THE WIDE ANGLE: Princeton's 64 Telescopes Just Broke the Comet Model

A 12-sigma anomaly, inflated error bars, and the 5.6-sigma flash they deleted from the official record.

View original source

Key Claims

6
  • The article states that four teams have independently confirmed that the exterior of 3I/ATLAS is driving the interior.factual
    Four teams have now independently confirmed the exact same thing.
  • The article states that Princeton's data shows 3I/ATLAS brightens faster when more of the outer structure is included in the frame.factual
    Princeton just measured it the simplest way possible: they widened their camera lens. And they found that the more of the outer structure they included in the frame, the faster the object was brightening.
  • The article claims that the Princeton team artificially inflated error bars to fit the data into a standard comet model.factual
    Buried in Section 3 is a staggering admission: the data didn’t fit the comet model, so the authors artificially inflated their own error bars until the mathematical discrepancy disappeared.
  • The article states that a 5.6-sigma brightness spike was scrubbed from the dataset.factual
    On May 23, 2025, while digging through these archives, HATPI detected 3I. According to their own models, the object should have been incredibly faint. Instead, it was 5.6-sigma brighter than expected.
  • The article claims that 3I/ATLAS shows no intra-night variability, indicating anomalous stability.factual
    Once 3I was bright enough to measure clearly, the Princeton team examined twelve straight nights of data looking for short-term flickering or pulsing. They found nothing.
  • The article claims that 3I/ATLAS released Cyanide, Nickel, and Iron during the inbound heating phase but no Carbon (C2) until post-perihelion.factual
    During the inbound heating phase, 3I released Cyanide (CN), Nickel, and Iron. But the Princeton team confirmed there was no Carbon (C2) in the envelope.

Evidence

5
Princeton's HATPI datasetPrinceton team observations
data
Shanghai radio dataShanghai team
data
Korea optical mappingKorea team
data
Loeb's exhaust measurementsLoeb's team
data
HATPI pre-discovery server archivesPrinceton team
data

Event timeline

3
July 1, 2025

Official discovery of 3I/ATLAS

3I/ATLAS was officially discovered.

May 23, 2025

5.6-sigma brightness spike

HATPI detected 3I with a significant brightness spike.

May 1 through September 13, 2025

Princeton's HATPI observations

Princeton team extracted observations of 3I spanning this period.